Home | Links | Contact Us | Bookmark
Legal Forum Search :
   Homepage      News     Legal Directories      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Legal Forum    Military
Legal Discussion Forum

 how many UK MPs have children serving in Iraq/Afghanistan?
...


 If you had a choice, which would you choose?
Fort Bliss or Fort Drum..Also why? ...


 why did the U.S. drop the atomic bomb in Nagasaki?

Additional Details
i want facts not just "to win the war"...


 i know its been posted before, but please read?
Merry Christmas, My Friend


By James M. Schmidt, a Marine Lance Corporal
stationed in Washington, D.C., in 1986
Twas the night before Christmas, he lived all alone,
In ...


 How many soldiers duz it take to make a troop?
...


 What is your worst experience in the military?
I'm ready to hear it......figure I'd hear the horror stories before I join to really know what I'm getting into

Note: What you say probably won't affect my choice for ...


 How many countries has america dropped bombs on since the end of world war 2?
Someone told me it is 160, is that true it sounds impossible to ...


 Why wasn't the Confederate flag banned after the civil war ended?
The Confederate flag is the flag of the Confederate States, ie the Southern States that seceded before the start of the Civil War. Since the North won the Civil War and the South was defeated, why ...


 What happened to the US calvary?
...


 People in the military: Did I deserve to get yelled at?
So I sign up for the army reserve.We was introduction our selves. It was my turn and I said
my name is Jose and I come here' to get a good workout.
The drill Sergeant said
'T...


 Attention: wifes Do you like your husband being in the Army and why? free child care? free food?
schools? living on post? if living on post are your neighbors nice?
Additional Details
My neice left with her husband in the Army and I am trying to figure out if Army life is good?...


 What Branch of Military is better?
Marines

Navy

Airforce

Specal forces

Navy Seals

A...


 Why don't the military tell the truth ?
It's all propaganda. Millions spent on 100% acurate long range missiles , I saw them on TV during the Saddam thing, they could hit a tank or rocket launcher 100 miles away.
All complete BS ...


 i;m planning on joining the army but i only wanna do it for 5 yrs. will i just be able to walk away after that?
what is the best branch to join?
Additional Details
am thinking of prob joining the CIA after that......


 How are you going to vote, for a hero or a zero?
...


 when will the killing stop in Iraq?
...


 Ugh.. just signed up to take the asvab for the army...?
I go to a community college this is my first year. I've been feeling a bit down lately and I can't find a job for anything so the army kept popping up in my head. After someone told me you ...


 What happens if Iraq becomes a Vietnam?
...


 If, you could go back in time and Kill Hitler. Would you?
...


 US military superiority is it so advanced?
I love the US but all the talk really. All you hear is Stealth this and Stealth that. Do you think countries in Europe have really stop advancing since ww2? uk invented radar ok we haven't built ...



lg304621942
Can the president declare war without congressional approval?
I was reading the article in the news about how congress has warned the president that he doesn't have the authority to attack Iran, However I thought I read somewhere that the president can take action for I believe is 60 days until he need congressional approval. What seems strange is that once that door is open "WAR" I belive you need all parties to decide to end it. Anyone care to give insight?
Additional Details
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070119/ap_on_go_co/us_iran



Show all answers
Post your answer

Paul B
Accordfing to the Constitution of the United States only Congress has the power to "Declare War".

When Congress gave Bush permission to punish Iraq for violating the sanctions it did not give him the power to invade and destroy the country.

Bush took that upon himself and he should be held accountable for it!

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



clay e
Rating
no he cannot declare war with out congressional approval,but can he can use his powers as commander in chief to send troops into situations that are equal to war as stated in the constitution.there is no 60 or 90 day time limit to it.the 1st time this was done was between 1797 and 1799 when george washington use the navy to attack french raiders who were capturing our ships.jefferson did it agien in 1801 to stop the muslim barbary pirates of the north african countries. mckinley did this in 1900 during the boxer rebellion in china.hoover and roosevelt in the 1920's and 1930's in various south american and caribean countries.truman in 1950-53 in korea,kennedy,johnson in the 60's for vietnam,reagan in granada,bush #1 in operation desert storm.as long as the president believes there is a threat to american interest are threatened he can use force.no this is not an illegal war by any means execpt by liberal know nothings.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



orange blossom honey
yes he can for i think its 60 or 90 days then he needs approval.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Team Chief
Rating
No, only the Congress can delcare war.

The War Powers Resolution states that the President can order US troops into action for not more than 60 days without the support of congress; after that, one of two things must happen: the troops must come home, or congress must approve the action.

News flash for all you liberal Bush-haters - CONGRESS APPROVED THE INVASION OF IRAQ. Therefore, Bush has NOT done anything illegal.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Bob G
Rating
The topic certainly leaves room for debate.

I think the intention of the Constitution is that only Congress can declare war, but the nation has to retain the capability to respond to an attack regardless of whether Congress is in session or not (at the time the Constitution was ratified, trains hadn't even been invented). Making the President Commander-In-Chief of the military provides a capability for rapid response to a crisis.

A literal interpretation of the Constitution gives the President the authority to start a war on his own. In fact, a literal interpretation allows the President to wage armed conflict as long the 'war' label isn't attached to it. That's kind of a catch-22. If Congress doesn't declare war, then the President isn't conducting a war and isn't violating the Constitution. I think that's a bizarre interpretation.

The War Powers Act you refer to was an attempt to close any possible loop hole. Ideally, the fact that the President would need Congressional approval to continue any armed conflict past 60 days would prevent a President from waging an undeclared war like the Korean War or the Viet Nam War. In practice, it works more like you said. Once the President has committed to a war, Congress is backed into a corner and will find it very hard to tell the President to withdraw troops.

In the case of Iraq, the War Powers Act is a moot point since Bush got Congressional approval months before he invaded Iraq. In fact, the Senate debate on that resolution makes some pretty interesting reading. Winslow Wheeler wrote a good article about it called "The Week of Shame".
http://www.mafhoum.com/press4/shame.pdf#search='winslow%20t%20wheeler

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Ronin
Rating
Theoretically, no he can't .
Practically, yes he can and does.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



mark
Yes

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



liberal democratic republican
Rating
The President can call forces into action for up to 60 days without Congressional approval. After that 60 days, he can get an additional 30 day, but only if he can prove that it is vital to National security to do such. Then he must have the support of Congress to fund any further action, else he has to withdraw the forces.

Simply put to all of those whining about our military being in an "illegal war", If the war is illegal and not wanted by so many in Congress, why is Congress still funding it? Be aware that it takes more than a simple majority to maintain funding, so there's lots of Democrats voting for continuation.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Sick Puppy
Rating
I don't know about emergency executive decisions (if there is such a thing), but no, the President must go via Congress. It's the three branches of government which keeps the balance of power even.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Leogirl0804
I don't think he can. That is why we had not just one landslide approval vote on Iraq, but two of them.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Truth B. Told I Told You So
Rating
Have you forgotten about the overwhelming majority of politicians that voted for this war, no to mention whho admitted they thought there were WMD's? Check the link I have listed below for a reminder:

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Critter Lady
Actually, the law allows the president to declare war and act upon that declaration for 60 days, without consent of Congress.

Unfortunately for Bush, those 60 days passed a long time ago, so yes, his actions are illegal at this time. If Congress says to shut it down, he has no choice but to comply.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No






Archive: Forum - Forum - Links - Links1 - Links2 - RSS - All RSS Feeds
Trusted legal information for you. 0.074
Copyright (c) 2007-2010 Find Legal Advice Friday, August 29, 2014 - All rights reserved - Terms of use - Privacy Policy