Home | Links | Contact Us | Bookmark
Legal Forum Search :
   Homepage      News     Legal Directories      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Legal Forum    Law & Ethics
Legal Discussion Forum

 New York Times- guilty of treason??
why is it that reporter get mad when the Congressmen hide behind thier offices when acting unethically and/or illegally, yet have no problem hiding behind the First amendment ? I just want to know if ...


 I got a ticket for using my blow up doll on the carpool lane ! How unfair ! Who should i write to?
...


 Do you think Obama will react decisively when confronted with his first international crisis?
...


 !!!!! How sad is this?
I live in north london im 15, and some things you hear are bad, but this happened a few years ago at a pub near me:

There was a young man (about 22) who was a student, he even went to ...


 Sex Offender OFFENDERS UNFAIRLY TREATED? They should be treated as others after released? (Share you thoughts)
Now, I have a question about Sex Offender Laws. (My sister and I argue about this all the time. I respect his opinion but I don't think that he respects mine, but we love each other just the ...


 If we're one nation under god why do we allow pornography?
...


 What do you do if you find a suitcase with one million dollars in which the owner's address is also there?
...


 IN U.S. will the law forgive the criminal if the plaintiff forgives him/her ?
...


 Why can't people just give answers instead of insulting comments?
People come here for advice and information, not to be put down and isulted. Why are people so mean? If you are perfect and have no problems, and know it all, then why are you on here?
A...


 Is this a scam or not??? Money wiring?
Okay so i have something on craigslist. and this one dood wanted to buy it. I had a long talk on hotmail with him and finally he just told me to wait.! So i did. and He wired me this one check of $2,4...


 Do you think that if people around the US were aloud to carry conceiled weapons, the crime rate would go down?

Additional Details
Only some states have passed the law....


 Isn't prostitution illegal in the U.S.?
Isn't prostitutions (sex for money) illegal in the united states? If so, how are bunny ranches, escort services etc. legal? Heidi Fleiss is opening a LEGAL brothel soon, how is that possible?...


 When Can You Tell a Co-Worker Their Religion Is Ridiculous?
I think that people should be free of all types of harassment in the workplace. I think that this includes sexual, religious, ethnic and so forth.

The ACLJ and the Liberty Counsel tell us ...


 Which is the best law to follow?
...


 Should you be able to defend family and property?
in the uk the law says you can use reasonable force which basically means restraining the assailant but if you hurt them you have to prove they hurt you first how stupid is that! you actually have to ...


 Do you think it should be legal to commit suicide?
I believe that the courts should stay out of a person's choice to take their own life. Especially in cases where untreatable pain is involved. This assumes a person is sane and can make ...


 Do you think marijuana should be a legal alternative for the alcoholic?
...


 Why do Obama's supporters believe Healthcare is a "fundamental right?"?
I just saw an Obama supporter on the O'Reily Factor claim that all Americans deserve good healthcare. She said that healthcare is a "fundamental right" and should be a constitutional ...


 Can i get into america with quite a big criminal record?
possesion of a knife, possesion of class c drug, malicious mischief, breach of the peace x5, resisting arrest x 4
plus much more usual drunkin crap any help thank ...


 Where can a criminal on the run seek refuge in this day and age?
...



lonepiper
Can a landlord be sued for Carbon Monoxide poisoning?
A friend of mine owns a house in Toronto, Canada and one of her tenants recently suffered from Carbon Monoxide poisoning. The landlord had two working CO detectors in the house. Can she be sued? Is she liable for what happened?



Show all answers
Post your answer

Lewisthelab
Rating
Yes if it's caused by smokers in their pub

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Naughty Girl*
Rating
hellllll yeah, its there job to maintain the house in proper living conditions.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



God Bless America!~
yes i believe she is liable for what did happen

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



killingspree27
if the landlord didnt tell u about the monoixde then yes you can. the land lord has to tell you every thing about the house before he sells it to any body. so id say go ahead and sue him.good luck

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Jarhead
yes!

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



aaron_tbrook
In California they can, unless they provided an alarm.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



¸.•*´`*♥To0DaMnFaBuL0uS♥*´`*•.¸
possibly because since the detectors didn't work there must be something wrong and thats the landlords fault but maybe no cause she at least installed it in and wasn't really her fault there was carbon monoxide although some of it is!good luck!

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Andy
Yes, in general, it is the landlord's duty to furnish a safe apartment to tenant.

Of course, there is mitigating ground, but I can't comment with just the little facts you gave us. For example, did the tenant do something to increase the CO level, say to block the exhaust from the gas hot water boiler? The fact that she has put two CO detectors will help the landlord's case to show that she has tried to fulfill her duty. This is either negate her liability, or reduce the damages. Another factor could be if CO poisoning happened in the same apartment, but she did not investigation or repair, but merely buy two CO detector. That will hurt her case.

Since it is all based on facts, I can only tell you that in general, she is liable, but there is always "wiggle room." She needs a lawyer.

These are my opinion and not to be used as legal advice. I am not a lawyer.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



gemini
Rating
That's a tuff one. If the detectors didn't alert the tenants, then the detector maker could be help liable. If your friend is smart, they should contact a lawyer now to see what liability they may have.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



_I_love_warm_bananas_
Rating
If whatever caused the poisoning came with the house, she can be held liable. If it was caused by something purchased, installed, and maintained by the occupants, she cannot be held liable. For instance, if the occupants purchased a gas stove, they are responsible for the proper care of that appliance and are at fault if it causes carbon monoxide poisoning.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



gomanyes562
I'm not familiar with Ontario law, but I think it would be a good case. Definitely contact a lawyer and look into it.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



linz_b
i guess she COULD be sued, but that doesn't mean that they will win. if she had working detectors in the home and no knowledge of CO2 problems, i don't think she can be held accountable for that, but you might want to check with an attorney

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



justbeingher
As long as the detectors were maintained and installed as recommended, the homeowner probably will be considered to have taken care of their responsibility - but like another poster said - the manufacturer of the alarm may also be sued.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



lmmvirago
This is the law in the US:

8. Are you a Landlord? Have you been carrying out statutory checks? Even if you have, you may be liable if one of your tenants becomes ill or worse, dies. Fit a Detector for your own and your tenants' piece of mind. As a Landlord, you have to show Due Diligence. If you are found guilty of neglect you may be fined or even sent to prison. Could you live with the consequences for the rest of your life?

And here's an article about a death in Canada:

Landlord jailed for CO death

Christopher Woffenden, 33, a tenant of Mohammed Ola, died from Carbon Monoxide poisoning caused by a defective gas fire at a property in Batley. Ola, his landlord, who received a 15-month jail sentence at Leeds Crown Court, failed to have gas appliances at the house checked since he bought the property in 1996.

Judge Norman Jones described Ola's behaviour as "reckless" after he ignored warnings about the condition of the appliance which ultimately caused loss of life. The Judge said Ola was guilty of gross negligence, stating: "I am satisfied that you understood that warning, that it would cost money to do so and you therefore hid your head in the sand and did not do what you were required, to protect the safety of your tenants. It is to reflect your culpability for your wrongdoing, and I want it clearly known in cases that if death or injury ensues from landlords ignoring their responsibilities, custodial sentences will follow."

Mr Woffenden's brother Stephen said of the sentence: "Justice has been done and though it won't bring Chris back the sentence helps a little bit."

If the landlord is checking the detectors it is questionable. Where is the leak? Are they responsible for the appliance that is causing the problem? If not, that's another matter.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Daniel T
Rating
It sort of depends. Because since the carbon monoxide detectors were working than it should've gone off which would make your friends get out of the house. But if it was caused because of maybe little or no maintenance than you probaly can sue. You can always consult a lawyer and ask them for free. But make sure you know the law first before you take action. hope this helps.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Trish
Rating
if there were CO detectors and they were working.....
I don't see how she can be held liable, but these days you just never know.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



davidmi711
Is she liable for what happened? - Depends on what happened. Renter ran a generator in the house with the doors and windows closed? Probably not liable. Renter has complained about the heater stinking for the last few months and the heater caused the problem? Likely to be liable.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No






Archive: Forum - Forum - Links - Links1 - Links2 - RSS - All RSS Feeds
Trusted legal information for you. 0.014
Copyright (c) 2007-2010 Find Legal Advice Monday, November 24, 2014 - All rights reserved - Terms of use - Privacy Policy