Home | Links | Contact Us | Bookmark
Legal Forum Search :
   Homepage      News     Legal Directories      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Legal Forum    Law Enforcement & Police
Legal Discussion Forum

 Is it justice... or just, what's right?


My little sister was killed over a year ago in a car accident.. Yes, she was 15 & out way past her curfew but that isn't the point. She was with her boyfriend, he was driving... W...


 I want to know if there is a warrant out for my arrest?
...


 Is it right to stop and breathalyse motorists in the morning?
recently in the west i think it was there was a drink drive campaign, a string of police officers taken off the beat to stop every sinlge motorist on a certain stretch of road at 8 o'clock in ...


 Why don't cops take responsability for their own actions?

Additional Details
i mean you ever relize cops are the only ones saying their nice?...


 Will O.J. Simpson write another book while he's in prison? What would be a good title for it?
...


 Would anyone say voluntary coppers are the same as full time police officers?
...


 Why is The Police Taking so Long?
I called about an hour ago about a break-in and entering and they still have not arrived. Is this really protecting and serving? Now I do love the police for there services but taking to long to ...


 When you get arrested can you request the police officers sterilize the handcuffs or do they do it already?
I mean, come on, there are prostitutes drug dealers and poor people who touched those things. If i get arrested I'm going to MAKE them clean it off. It's one or the other, either clean them ...


 Should he have been arrested?
On YouTube,a couple of older guys(17 maybe)went to a crowded mall with a video camera.They decided to see what would happen if one of them faked a seizure.....so they did...and 911 was called-out of ...


 Do you think we should have a zero tolerance police force?
get rid off the judge & jury and let the police do on the spot fines or sentencing to prison....


 Should I be "arrested" for extra credit?
Well here is the deal. First off, we're still in school (I'm doing this in study hall and need to know what I should do ASAP). Our Summer Break is only like three weeks long, but we get ...


 Was i right for calling the cops?
i called the cops on some kids that were being harrased by kids in a car.first they chased the kids with a knife then the kids were on their porch and the car came by and stopped in front of the ...


 Is it ethical or honorable for a cop to lie to a judge?
I'm not talking about under oath,so it is not a legal issue....


 My friend has 3 felony warrants in ny, and he is overseas now but he wants to come back will he goto jail?
AT THE AIRPORT?...


 Pulled over by cop, What should I do?
I got pulled over coming out of my works parking lot. This a private parking lot is owned by at&t. There is no posted stop/yeild sign. The cop stated that I failed to stop...and wrote me a $147 ...


 Who likes cops?
i dont really like the cops because they think there all that because they have a gun but if they dident have a gun stuner gun back up they wouldent be nothing and especially think they are all that ...


 Conjoined twins commit murder and a court finds him/her guilty what happens to the innocent half?
...


 What is the best non-lethal force against anti-war protestors?
When anti-war protestors refuse to disperse, what is the best non-lethal force to use? Batons? Tear Gas? Rubber bullets?
http://www.commondreams....


 Will you call 911?????
call 911 and say i need the ambulance i have broken my ...


 Do you think Mark Chapman should be released?
He has served 26 years of his sentence. Do you think he should be released at his next parole meeting which will be 28 years?...



Haley D
Cops:reading you your rights?
is it against the law for the cops to not read you your rights when they arrest you?
Additional Details
they already searched the truck and put the people in handcuffs



Show all answers
Post your answer

bcnd
Rating
yes. They must read you your marada rights

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



>♥Cat♥<
Rating
yes, it definitely is! It's called the Miranda rights!! As soon as they put you under arrest, they have to read you your rights! That's the law, and if they don't, that evidence cannot be used in a Court of Law

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



†Absinthe†
Yes.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Cin Reaper
Rating
Some kids watch too much TV. A cop need only confirm that you are aware of your rights, not necessarily read them to you word for word. For example, a lawful arrester might say"Do you understand your rights, like you can remain silent" If the arrested says "Yeah, yeah." That's good enough.
Back when the Miranda ruling was new, the standard was more strict.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Steven C
If you are arrested for a major felony yes if it is a simple misdemeanor then no. It is standard for felony charges.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



ja man
Rating
well you'd think so but I have been arrested and not had my rights read until I got to the jail and was in the booking process although that was like 10 years ago

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



kattz
Rating
no only if they are questioning you but not if they just arrest you. by now most people should know that is one of your rights and whether an officer informs you of it or not the best thing is to remain silent until you have an attorney present. that way you protect your rights.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



mike g
Rating
only when you are being charged of a crime and being questioned

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Iqbal
I agree with the Fishguy.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



kyghostchaser2006
Miranda merely states you must be read and understand your rights before questioning in a crime you may have committed. If you fail to understand or are not read your rights then any statement made after the fact may not be admissable in court. It doesn't mean your case is thrown out but your statements against yourself maybe. Other evidence could lead to your conviction.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



wfsgymwear
Rating
Many of you watch to much TV...First off it is Miranda Warning. Not rights. And, You only have to be read the warning if you are under arrest, not free to leave, and being questioned. Also, You have to be questioned about the crime or specifics of the crime. Your name, DOB, address, etc, are types of information not covered under the Miranda Warning. Now here is a question for you...Did you know Miranda was named after a dirtbag who was let off for a crime and later killed by another shxxbag. He should have just been a man and admitted he messed up...

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



shewolf3808
Rating
No.

The officer only needs to tell you what you are being arrested for.

A person is not read their rights under Miranda until prior to being questioned and at that point you receive your rights both verbally and most often in writing.

And if you are in the back of the patrol car and you blurt out that you just committed a crime, without being asked, you may not be protected by the 5th amendment because it is considered a excited utterance which can be used against you.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



tallerfella
Rating
Only if they question you. And it's not really against the law anyway. They can't be arrested for not advising you of your rights.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



El Scott
Rating
Kenneth (above post) has it right.

The Police do not have to read Miranda to you. In fact I rarely read it to people I arrest.

The only thing I might add that I don't think Kenneth touched on and I saw another poster screw up was this:
If you get arrested and start talking about your crime (without being asked about it by the Police) then the officer still does not need to read Miranda to you. In other words if you just start talking about a crime it can be held against you.

Kenneth gets the thumbs up here.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Coach
Rating
No it is not illegal for the police to arrest you without advising you of your miranda rights. This is usually done prior to any questioning being accomplished. They do have to tell you what you are being arrested for.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Vindicaire
Rating
NO! Police only need to read your Miranda Rights under two conditions...and both must be met.

1) You must be in custody.
2) You must be being interrogated by the police.

As a street officer the only times I had to read a suspect Miranda Rights was on misdemeanor domestic assault cases.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



coragryph
No.

There is no requirement that you have any rights read to you when arrested.

Read the Miranda holding. The requirement to read so-called Miranda rights only applies to "custodial interrogation".

Arrest counts as "custody". However, if the cops are not interrogating you, then the Miranda rules don't apply.

FYI, interrogation is defined as either asking questions, or making statements likely to provoke an incriminating response.

But, if there is no conversation or interrogation, then the failure to read rights has no implications on whether the arrest itself was valid.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Great constitutional analysis by KennethC (above). Kudos.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Smahteepanties
It is not against the law for the cops to read you your rights when they arrest you. As long as they have probable cause and believe that the suspect has committed a crime, the arrest is valid.

When a suspect is in custody and being interrogated then, by right, the Officer should read him/her their rights. If the Miranda Rights was not given during the time of interrogation any information given prior to the Rights being read or given, is inadmissible. Anything after the Miranda Rights is admissible.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Officer
Miranda comes into play only when you reach both circumstances of:

1) being under arrest
2) being interrogated

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Fishguy
Rating
No.

They only need to read those to you if they are going to ask you any questions about the crime in question. If they are arresting you because they have a warrant, there is no need.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



Kenneth C
NO!

There is no law at all for it. It is considered a prophylactic rule.

Police only have to read you your rights when you are in custody and being questioned about a crime. Pedigree information doesn't count as being questioned (name, age, DOB, ect)

So if you are arrested for driving while suspended, the officer will probably never read your rights because he probably won't question you. And that is perfectly acceptable.

Miranda covers the 5th amendment (self incrimination portion). Arrest is a 4th amendment issue. So Miranda doesn't come into play until you are being question.

If police fail to mirandize you and you are questioned. Only the questions they ask and your answers or confession would be thrown out. Not the entire arrest or any other evidence (unless it was found due to your confession)

In the original Miranda case, Ernesto Miranda was still convicted of some of his crimes. Just his confession was thrown out.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No



♥ ♥Be Happi♥ ♥
Yes, they need to read you your rights prior to any questioning, if you start talking without them asking any questions, they need to read you your rights.

Was this answer helpful to you?  Yes  /  No






Archive: Forum - Forum - Links - Links1 - Links2 - RSS - All RSS Feeds
Trusted legal information for you. 0.034
Copyright (c) 2007-2010 Find Legal Advice Friday, October 31, 2014 - All rights reserved - Terms of use - Privacy Policy